FREE SHIPPING on Orders Over $750

Peanut Butter Topping (2.5 Pound Jar)

Peanut Butter Topping (2.5 Pound Jar)


Create the perfect sundae with our All Natural Peanut Butter Topping (also called Peanut Butter Syrup and/or Peanut Butter Sauce). The flavor of fresh, creamy peanut butter. This product flows like hot fudge but requires no heating, adheres to ice cream or soft serve beautifully, and tastes terrific with hot fudge or chocolate, nuts, marshmallow, crunches, bananas and other fruits. Excellent over Ice Cream! Other applications include Peanut Butter Smoothies or Shakes and Peanut Butter Latte. This pourable Peanut Butter is also Great for Baking and Cooking. Peanut Butter Topping - Net WT. 2.5 Pound.

  • Store refrigerated for up to 6 months. We do not recommend freezing.
  • This is an All Natural Product made wihout any hydrogenated oils.
  • Oil separation can occur naturally. Be sure to mix thoroughly each time before using.
  • This product is certified Kosher Pareve.


37 Reviews
81% (30)
14% (5)
5% (2)
0% (0)
0% (0)
84% Recommend this product (31 of 37 responses)
New York
The Real Deal
August 21, 2019
This sauce is just like the "good stuff" you get at the ice cream shops. An excellent product, I've used it primarily on ice cream (coffee and vanilla) and frozen yogurt as a topping.
Better than Dairy Queen’s
August 18, 2019
Grand children say your peanut butter topping is better than Dairy Queen‚€™s. Enough said. I will order again, Thank you for a really good product!
February 8, 2018
Best peanut butter sauce, perfect on ice cream. And fabulous customer service!
Great Peanut Butter Topping
December 30, 2015
Bought this for Christmas to go on top of our brownie sundaes. It was excellent.
ProsIt taste great
ConsHave to stir, and if you keep in the frig it's harder to stir before using. Still works though.
Port St Lucie, Fl
December 1, 2013
Grew up in Baltimore and always went to Friendlys for ice cream. Have been looking for sauce that came CLOSE to theirs.THIS is it!!!! Not only comes close, but SURPASSES it!!! My kids now know the taste of MY childhood ice cream!!!! Ty SO much sand I will order from you AGAIN!!!!
ProsIt's DELICIOUS!!! :)
Wilmington, Delaware
Exceptional Peanut Butter Topping
October 27, 2013
I view ice cream as simply a vehicle for toppings. Peanut butter topping is my favorite, and this peanut butter topping is exceptional. Bought it originally as a gift for a friend looking for Friendly's PB topping replacement, and this is as close as it gets. Many other reviewers have said that, and it's true.
Parkland, Florida
October 26, 2013
Ice cream parlor quality!!! You can't go wrong with this item!
New York
Best peanut butter topping out there
September 7, 2013
This topping is the closest I've been able to find to ice cream parlor dessert toppings. It lasts a long time & tastes great, perfect for ice cream or even just to add a touch of peanut butter to some whipped cream.
Seaford, De 19973-7720
June 13, 2013
Makes a great PB milkshake
The best peanut butter topping out there!!
April 3, 2013
I have a friend that disparately want the peanut butter topping that DQ serves. Unfortunately you can't buy it from them. I searched and searched and got the all natural peanut butter topping for my friend as a gift. He said it was the best!! It tasted just like the peanut butter topping that DQ serves. It may be expensive, especially when you pay the shipping but it is well worth it. I promise!
ProsFlavor is great, 2.5 lbs is a lot of peanut butter topping. My friend says that it is great on oreos.
ConsHigh shipping but understandable
Needham, MA
Peanut Butter Topping Make Wife Verrry Happy
February 12, 2013
So the wife's a peanut butter junkie for sure. And peanut butter sauce, now we're entering another stratosphere. Superior Nut Store's Peanut Butter Topping is fantastic and well worth the cost. Local (Boston area) ice cream shop J.P. Licks carries something similar, but shelling out $5+ for a small scoop just to get the PB sauce on top hurts in the wallet big-time. While this peanut butter sauce is pricey, it's still way more reasonable than what an ice cream store can offer. These are big jars, and they last a while. It's yummy and the wife is satisfied.
ProsTaste; Size; Availability
ConsA little thick (though heating will fix this); Price
Morris MN
December 29, 2012
My son has been wanting a peanut butter syrup for a long time and this one was a winner!!!
Excellent Choice
November 7, 2012
I looked everywhere for a topping that rivals those in the Yogurt shops. This peanut butter topping does just that. The taste is superb and it is easy to use. Not stiff not runny. Go easy though. It is made with high fructose corn syrup. You could easily go overboard and jeopardize the waistline. Very yummy though!
ProsFlavor and consistency.
ConsHigh fructose corn syrup.
Gresham, OR
This topping is yummy!
October 11, 2012
I love peanut butter! This topping is great on vanilla ice cream with a little hot fudge. A local chain has a dessert that uses peanut butter topping and I was hoping to find something similar. This product exceeded my expectations. It's a little expensive with shipping, but I will buy it again.
ProsNot too sweet and just enough salty.
ConsDon't like the fact that it has corn syrup.
Green Bay, WI
Fantastic Peanut Butter Topping
September 26, 2012
I have been searching for years for a product that I could find to duplicate the peanut butter topping that Culver's restaurants use for sundaes. Finally, success! This is an excellent product. I would recommned it to anyone.
ProsExcellent flavor and consistency.
ConsNot a thing.
Just OK, and too expensive
August 8, 2012
The topping is pretty good, but not nearly worth the price. When you add shipping onto it, the proposition becomes very spendy. I like the product, but would only buy it in a store, and certainly NOT at the current level of pricing. Delivery was very quick, on the plus side.
ProsQuick delivery
ConsPrice and shipping cost
Chicago, IL
Great!!! Order, don't hesitate.
July 23, 2012
This was exactly what I have been looking for in the grocery stores for years...and haven't been able to find. You will not be disappointed with the item. The peanut butter sauce is free-flowing, smooth, and tastes rich without being too sweet. If you have been a patron of Friendly's or DQ and like their peanut butter sundaes, you can order this item and make them at home exactly to your liking...and save money in the long-term.
ProsTaste Size availability (2.5, 6.5, and 45 lbs) Texture
ConsHave to order online, not available in area stores Cost of shipping
Peanut butt topping
June 22, 2012
Very good
Plattsburgh, NY
The BEST Peanut Butter Topping!
June 1, 2012
Just as good as Friendly's or any other ice cream joint. LOVE it.
So Good!
April 14, 2012
I bought this because other reviewers said how good it was and I was looking for a topping that mimicked the Friendly's Reeses Peanutbutter sundae. I'm so glad I listened to the other reviewers...this stuff is DELICIOUS.
Beverly, MA
Just like Friendly's
March 30, 2012
This peanut butter topping is just like the topping used by Friendly's on their Reese's Pieces sundae. Excellent!
Peanut butter topping
March 29, 2012
Not to many peanut butter toppings around that are good and that you can buy in bulk. I like this topping. This is #1 to me compared to the other few peanut butter toppings around.
ProsGreat taste, just the right size jar. Fast shipping.
ConsNothing, the only thing i did not like is the shipping cost but besidesthat will buy this product again and again. Yummmmmie!!!!!
Burlington, NC
March 18, 2012
Interestingly, I was at our company location in France and one of our colleagues there spent a year in Connecticut and happened to mention how she loves peanut butter and Friendleys peanut butter sauce. I had never heard of Friendleys but set out on a mission to find peanut butter sauce to send to her. It wasnt easy but after searching on line, found your peanut butter sauce. I ordered one to send to my colleague and two for my family. It is delicious and I can't wait for my new friend in France to receive her surprise!
Asheville, NC
March 2, 2012
My husband has an obession with a certain ice cream chain's peanut butter topping. We have looked all over for something equivalent. But this is even better! He loves it! Thanks for an awesome product with the freshest of peanut tastes!
Belgrade, Maine
Pricey But Worth It
January 9, 2012
This is a great-tasting product. I'd recommend it to anyone.
ConsThe topping is a little expensive (especially with shipping costs).
New York City
Amazingly good!
October 18, 2011
We went through half a jar in the first week. Tastes great, not too sweet - highly recommended!!
ProsTastes great, doesn't need to be refrigerated.
ConsEating too much ice cream now!
East Tennessee
A Great Product
September 15, 2011
I use this product in my coffee house to make peanut butter lattes, frappes, and smoothies. The customers love the taste. I love the consistency of the product. It blends up very well and works well when paired with chocolate. Just remember to keep it stirred so the oil will not separate and rise to the top.
White Oak, MO
In Love!
July 18, 2011
I saw a similar type of item being used at a restaurant, so I immediately got online to see what I could find. I was kind of suprised when I was able to order this item. Thanks to Superior Nut Company, I now have my very own supply of Peanut Butter Topping. AND it tastes GREAT!
Warrenton, VA
July 13, 2011
This peanut butter sauce was delicious! I have half a jar left and just got it in the mail a few weeks ago. I can't get enough of it. It's great on ice cream. Better than Friendly's topping! Shipping was fast!
Grove Cty, Pennsylvania
Tasty product!
July 11, 2011
I was glad I found ths website and was able to get this wonderful peanut butter sauce. I bought 3 jars and have had sundaes 4 times in a week....can't get enough. It is sweet with great peanut butter taste. I'd recommend this to anyone who loves peanut butter.
New York
Authentic Peanut Butter Taste
March 27, 2011
I have looked for years for a peanut butter sauce that is like the one used by Friendly's restaurants on their ice cream. On a recent search of the Internet, I found a reference to Superior Nut's peanut butter sauce and decided to give it a try. It was very expensive, especially with shipping but I found the sauce not only equal to, but better than the taste of Friendly's brand. It is a smooth, creamy and easily pourable sauce, packed with peanut flavor. Stores well in the cupboard and does not need to be heated before serving. Delicious, if you can afford it.
ProsPeanut taste Creamy, pourable Delicious
ConsVery expensive Expensive Shipping cost
West Berlin, NJ
Great product!
February 18, 2011
I have been searching for peanut butter topping for so long. This is delicious! I love it. We pour it on ice cream and I also use it when I make homemade ice cream. I just stir it in at the end and it makes great peanut butter swirl ice cream.
South Burlington, VT
Great Product
February 4, 2011
This is my second order. The product is great, customer service is really good, and delivery was prompt. The only drawback is that I'm now eating more ice cream than before.
Review for
January 5, 2011
Excellent product.
Review for
October 31, 2010
So far so good, the product is going well, Thanks for shipping it UPS ..
Review for
July 18, 2010
The peanut butter topping is awesome. It is exactly what I have been searching for and I know I will order it again, soon, if I can√Ę‚‚¨‚"Ęt stop eating it! It is delicious.
Review for
December 19, 2009
This is the 2nd time I purchased the Peanut Butter topping as a gift for a relative who had a peanut butter sauce at a well known resort. As a surprise to her I found yours on the "net" and yours has been enjoyed.


Peanuts, Peanut and/or Cottonseed Oil, High Fructose Corn Syrup and Salt.

This product is certified Kosher Pareve.

Nutritional Info

Allergy Information: Contains Peanuts. This product  is produced at a facility that produces peanuts and tree nuts, may contain elements of tree nuts.
Serving Size 28g (about 1 oz)
Servings per pound: About 16
Calories per Serving: 154
Calories from Fat per Serving: 136

Total Fat: 16g; Saturated Fat: 2g; Trans Fat: 0g; Cholesterol: 0mg; Sodium: 174mg; Total Carbohydrate: 9g; Dietary Fiber: 1g; Sugars: 3g; Protein: 3g

% of Recommended Daily Allowance: Vitamin A: 0%, Vitamin C: 0%, Calcium: 0%, Iron: 6%
In stockUsually ships the same business day
For years we have provided customers with the highest quality Nuts, Candy & Dried fruits. Our customers know they can rely on us to deliver their package fresh and on time. Every item we sell, including Peanut Butter Topping 2.5 Pound Jar, comes with our 100% satisfaction guarantee promise. If you experience a problem with any of our products, customer service, shipping, or if you just don't like what you purchased, please let us know. We'll do whatever it takes to make it right.

At Nuts in Bulk you will find a large selection of Nuts and Dried Fruits. Some of our most popular products are almonds, cashews, walnuts, macadamias, pistachios, pecans, peanuts, brazils and pine nuts. All of our fresh and delicious products are offered in bulk sizes (1 to 5 pound bags) and in wholesale sizes (10 to 44 pound cases). At Nuts in Bulk, you can count on the same personal customer service and 100% satisfaction guarantee that we have provided our customers for over 80 years.